Short Pointers

February 4, 2014

One good thing with 64 bits addresses, is that you can, in principle, use essentially as much memory as you want—the address space certainly exceeds today’s computers’ capabilities. One bad thing, especially when you create lots of objects and need plenty of pointers, is that 64 bits pointers are big. They use 8 bytes of memory. One or two pointers aren’t a problem, of course, but what if your data structure is a sparse graph, each node being mostly pointers, and that you need to create a very large graph?

pincer-grip

One solution is to use stretch codes, as I proposed a while ago, trading off precision of addressing for shorter pointers. However, unless you rewrite the memory allocator, the technique won’t play well with the default new. Another solution is to store just barely the number of bits (rounded to bytes) necessary to hold an address. Can we do this? If so, how?

Read the rest of this entry »


Stretch Codes

September 9, 2008

About ten years ago, I was working on a project that needed to log lots of information and the database format that was chosen then was Microsoft Access. The decision seemed reasonable since the data would be exported to other applications and the people who would process the data lived in a Microsoft-centric world, using Excel and Access (and VBA) on a daily basis. However, we soon ran into a major problem: Access does not allow a single file to be larger than 2GB.

After sifting through the basically random error messages that had nothing to do with the real problem, we isolated the bug as being reaching the maximum file size. “Damn that’s retarded!” I remember thinking. “This is the year 2000! If we don’t have flying cars, can we at least have databases larger than 2GB!?“. It’s not like 2GB was a file size set far off into the future as are exabytes hard-drives today. There were 20-something GB drives available back then, so the limitation made no sense whatsoever to me—and still doesn’t. After the initial shock, I got thinking about why there was such a limitation, what bizarre design decision lead to it.

Read the rest of this entry »