A First Look At GPS Data

In previous installments, we looked at how to read data from a serial-over-USB GPS, then how to parse the data. However, getting data isn’t everything, we must also ascertain it’s valid

map-detail

The first thing that comes to mind to test the device’s precision (while I don’t really know how to check for the accuracy) by plug it in, leave it stationary, and collect the readings for a good while

I got two GPS of roughly the same capabilities:

  • The BU-353
  • The Columbus V800

I first got the BU-353, but it seemed finicky: it would not give a position reading unless it had more than 10 satellites in view, and once it decided to give position, it seemed jittery. The Columbus gives a reading even it there’s only a few satellites in view but “warns” us to treat the reading with low confidence by tagging the reading as V (void) in the $GPRMC message.

Grabbing data from the BU-353 over 72h yields:

bu-353

Where we see noise and drift. The data hasn’t been filtered or edited.

Grabbing data from the Columbus V800:

columbus-v800

Here again, we see comparable artifacts, with the Columbus V800 somewhat less dispersed. Overlapping the two graphs, we see that the Columbus V800 is less noisy:

bu-353-vs-columbus-v800

Looking at how the reading varies over time—the GPSes were laying against the case of the desktop computer, therefore as stationary as can be—is also interesting. Computing the difference (d_x,d_y)=(x_t-x_{t-1},y_t-y_{t-1}) and plotting them:

colombus-v800-delta

We see that the variation is not isotropic: it varies more in longitude than latitude. This jitter can certainly be used to enhance the reading, I am not sure how just now. Of course, the best would be to have the raw timing data from the GPS satellites and solve an over-complete equation system to find the most likely position and estimate the error. Unfortunately I do not have access to that data from the GPS: the $GPGSV is just enough to display the satellites on a screen, but way too coarse to get extra precision.

3 Responses to A First Look At GPS Data

  1. […] But in a next entry. To be continued… […]

  2. […] a few previous entries, we looked at how to capture, parse, and evaluate the precision of a NMEA-capable GPS. The next […]

  3. […] a few other entries, I’ve toyed with GPS, either getting or parsing the data with Bash, assessing or using the GPS data. However, when we use GPS, we suppose that the precision varies by brand and […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: